Procedural vote to table McCarthy motion to vacate vote fails in House

October 3, 2023

A procedural vote to table—or kill—an upcoming vote on a motion to vacate Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) from his leadership position failed in the House Tuesday afternoon.

Its failure means that the House will move forward with a motion to vacate.

The vote was scheduled after far-right Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL) on Monday evening made good on a threat to file a motion to vacate McCarthy from the Speakership, hours after he had accused McCarthy of having struck a “secret side deal” with President Biden and House Democrats to continue to fund Ukraine in its war against Russia.

Gaetz’s motion also came two days after McCarthy had introduced a “clean” 45-day stopgap spending bill to keep the government funded and avoided a shutdown; it passed in the GOP-led House after receiving more votes from Democrats that Republicans.

A motion to vacate is essentially calling for a “no confidence” vote against the House Speaker to have him or her ousted. There’s never been a successful vote to oust a House Speaker in the history of the U.S. Congress. 

However, a concession McCarthy made to far-right House members like Gaetz in January to secure the Speakership allows just one Representative—in this case, Gaetz—to make a motion to vacate the chair. Before McCarthy, a motion to vacate required a majority vote from members of the Speaker’s party.

Ahead of the vote Tuesday, McCarthy told reporters he was not counting on Democrats to help him save his job though he conceded, given Republicans’ razor-thin four-seat majority in the chamber, that “if five Republicans go with Democrats, then I’m out.”

By that point in the day, there were already a reported five conservative Republicans, including Gaetz, who were leaning toward voting for McCarthy’s ouster.

And House Democrats, who’d held a meeting earlier in the morning, had decided they were “not voting in any way that would help save Speaker McCarthy,” according to Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA), leader of the House Progressive Caucus. 

A vacancy in the Speaker’s chair would essentially paralyze the House until a successor is chosen, according to multiple procedural experts.

While McCarthy can, in fact, run for Speaker again, an interim Speaker would first be chosen from a list prepared by McCarthy and his staff at the beginning of the Congressional term, but staff intimately familiar with House rules have told the New York Ties that the role of that person would be to oversee a new Speaker election and little more.

PHOTO: House procedural vote on motion to vacate McCarthy

Read more exclusive news from Political IQ.



Get the featured stories in your email and don't miss out on important news.


AAA predicts busiest ever holiday travel season


AAA predicts busiest ever holiday travel season